A little clay, some DNA, and a novel idea

“This research gave me the confidence to trust my own ideas, and that has stayed with me ever since.”

Back in 2019

Explaining where a research idea came from can be challenging. Most of the time, we cannot trace it back to one moment. Trying to do so is still one of my favourite pastimes.

Here, I’ll share the idea behind eDNA passive sampling, how it came about, and how it changed my research. If you are new to environmental DNA (eDNA), I recommend watching this three-minute pitch before reading on.

The most common way to capture eDNA from water is to collect a sample in a bottle, filter it, and extract the DNA caught on the filter. But eDNA is not distributed evenly across a water body. Its distribution also changes over time. To detect rare DNA, you may need to be at “the right place at the right time.”

So, what if we could leave something in the water to collect eDNA over time?

The first eDNA passive-sampler prototype.

Where the idea began

I was a master’s student studying eDNA degradation in marine fish. While reading about the topic, I learned that adsorption, when DNA binds or sticks to particles such as sediment or clay, can protect it from degradation. Under certain conditions, DNA can remain preserved in sediments for centuries.

This threw a wrench into my plans to use eDNA to work out which species were currently present. How could I distinguish a recent signal from DNA that had been sitting there for years?

Some time later, I had a thought: “What if I add clean sediment with no eDNA to the water, then find out what DNA gets stuck to it?”

When I explained this to a postdoc colleague, he said, “Ah, so you want to make a passive sampler.”

And just like that, I had a name for the plan.

Making use of what was around

Next came the testing. I pitched the idea to my supervisor. She rightly reminded me that I needed to focus on the degradation work I had been hired to do. But I could use materials in the lab to run some tests on the side.

And so the work began!

We had granular activated carbon and montmorillonite clay left over from previous projects. We also had plenty of salmon DNA that a colleague was using for his experiments. I used these to run some preliminary trials.

Fatmucket mussels in the mesocosm tank.

I contacted an adsorption expert in my department. He generously taught me about adsorption isotherms and kinetics: how much DNA a material could bind, and how quickly it happened. These became the basis for testing the materials.

A former colleague had also kept fatmucket mussels, a large freshwater mussel species, in the lab. His project was finished, but we still had the qPCR assays, tanks, and notes on caring for the mussels. That gave us a starting point for experiments with live animals.

This became the mesocosm experiment.

The homemade holder for three replicate samplers.

From the lab to the river

I was already happy with the experimental setup. But my supervisor, now also getting excited by the preliminary results, encouraged me to test the samplers in the field. If I wanted the environmental science community to take the idea seriously, I needed to show that it worked outside the lab.

With a budget of $100, I sketched some designs and headed to the hardware store for PVC pipes and rods. Then, in my supervisor’s backyard, I used her power tools to drill holes and build holders for three replicate samplers.

We deployed them in a river near campus.

In the field! Testing deployment strategies

Together, these experiments became our first eDNA passive-sampling prototype and the paper describing it. It was also my first paper built around an idea that had originally been mine.

That work might be a drop in the ocean of scientific literature. But for me, it showed that I could come up with an original scientific idea and follow it through. That confidence has powered my research ever since.